Gregs Garage

Inspections performed here

• 3,324NY State inspections in the last 12 months
• 10,201inspections at this facility since 2023

What they inspect

• Initial Inspection3,164
• Re-Inspection160

Counted from NY DMV inspection-transaction records, not estimated.

Vehicles they inspect

• Motorcycles
• Trailers
• Cars and light trucks

Inspected 122 electric, 207 hybrid, and 14 diesel vehicles in the last 12 months.

From NY DMV inspection-transaction records for the last 12 months.

Hours and services

Monday

9 AM–5 PM

Tuesday

9 AM–5 PM

Wednesday

9 AM–5 PM

Thursday

9 AM–5 PM

Friday

9 AM–5 PM

Saturday

9 AM–1 PM

Sunday

Closed

• Onsite services
• Oil change
• Mechanic
• Wheelchair accessible entrance
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot
• Appointment required
• Appointments recommended
• Credit cards
• Debit cards
• NFC mobile payments
• Cash-only
• On-site parking

From this shop’s public Google Maps listing. Call ahead to confirm.

DMV licence

Facility number

7119326

Licence type

NYS Licensed Inspection Station, NYS Registered Repair Shop

Original issue date

June 7, 2019

Expires

March 31, 2027

Data from NY DMV as of September 2026. Check this facility in the NY DMV public record.

Reviews

★★★★☆ 4.3· 86 reviews on Google

• CChris★★★★★ June 26, 2025

  Local in Sag Harbor, and we had an emergency and Gregs really came through for us. They squeezed us in on incredibly short notice and really helped us out!!! Fast, extremely professional, and knowledgeable. Very grateful!!! 🙏🙏 Highly recommend!!!!!

• SSoupbone136★★★★★ August 22, 2024

  The Best Place for Auto Repair Friendly,Helpful and Affordable.. The Only Place to go when you need any help with your vehicle.. And NYS inspections.

• MMoira★☆☆☆☆ June 25, 2025
  Drove my car in to get the coolant system checked predominantly, as well as other brake/clutch checks as it's a vintage car and I wanted to make sure all was good. I went inside and handed the front desk man (who was very nice) the list of things I wanted done, noting that if they only had time to check the overheating issue then that's fine with me. He called Greg who said I could leave the car there for them to…

  work on. I left and got on a train out of town. 15 minutes later I got a call from them saying they don't have time for the work I want done and since it's "not my primary vehicle" (never said that to them, and actually don't have another vehicle) it's a winter project and not something they could do now. Asked if they could check my coolant at least, he said no since it's not an emergency. Then since I was already on a train and couldn't turn around, he said he'd charge me $35 per day if I can't come get it - I dropped it on a tuesday afternoon and would pick up thursday morning and somehow that counts as 3 full days. I said it was their mistake accepting the car in the first place then and he then charged me $30 to drive it back to my house 0.2 miles away. Truly don't care about customers or admitting when they were the ones mistaken.

• AAlexis★★★★★ August 17, 2025
  This isn’t your typical grease-and-grit garage. Greg’s place is part repair shop, part museum, part roadside carnival of curiosities. Everywhere you look there are colorful nicknacks, old cars with more stories than most people, and little details that make you wonder if you stumbled into a mechanic’s dreamscape. Greg himself? Definitely not your typical mechanic. He’s part car whisperer, part showman, and part…

  philosopher on four wheels. He’ll fix your engine, sure, but he might also teach you something about patience, timing, or why life’s better when your ride actually starts in the morning. The space has this electric vibe — alive with laughter, tools clinking, and the sense that something interesting is always happening. It’s less “waiting room dread” and more “Sag Harbor’s best-kept secret hangout spot… that also happens to fix cars.” If you’re tired of cookie-cutter garages and want an experience that’s as colorful as the nicknacks on the wall, this is your place. Greg’s the real deal — one of a kind.

• KKaren★☆☆☆☆ June 11, 2024
  I called beforehand to schedule an inspection appointment, which Greg gave me at 4 pm. I come in at 4, everything goes well, and I go to pay, and the bill comes out to $100. The regular charge should’ve just been $37, but since I “didn’t” have an appointment, according to the owner, Greg, he had to charge me for “Express Inspection,” not to mention he didn’t even have a receipt ready to give me; I had to ask him for…

  one. He then told me, yelling at me, “I told you it would be a $100 charge because you don't have an appointment.” Not only did he lie, but he scammed me. Not to mention, I’ve been here before for another vehicle of mine; I made the appointment the same day and was only charged $37. Don’t come here and save your money, not to mention he’s rude to his workers.

Snippets from public Google Maps reviews. Own this shop? Claim the page to reply.